Home      Contact      Index      FAQ's      Leave      Case Law      Purchase
Employee Trial Periods

Employers can employ new staff on trial periods, as long as they specify in writing that the employee is on a trial period - now also referred to as a "probationary arrangement".

The trial period can be as long as the employer considers it necessary to establish whether the employee can grasp the new job s/he has started. This could, for example, be a week, or could be as long as three months. The length of time is up to the employer. When deciding what length the trial period should be, the employer needs to remember that they must allow the employee the full length of the trial period to prove themselves capable, and cannot simply cut the time short, except on the grounds of misconduct or serious misconduct. And if there are issues of misconduct, or serious misconduct, then the employee must be afforded procedural fairness the same as any long serving employee. Failure to do so will result in successful personal grievance claims.

During the probationary period the employee should be advised on a regular basis how they are performing. If the employee has not been able to adequately perform a particular task, the employer should advise the employee of the correct way to do the task. This may happen on more than one occasion. The employee should also be told whether this could impact on the success of the trial period. This could be as simple as stating for example

"Three times now I have shown you the correct way to do this particular task, and you still have not grasped it. Unfortunately, if you cannot get it right, I will not be able to continue your employment beyond the trial period."

If the employer simply chooses to say nothing, and then at the end of the trial period, advises the employee that "things haven't worked out - here's a cheque for your wages and holiday pay", the employer will end up paying a few thousand more dollars once the personal grievance claim has settled. Why? Because the employee was never told s/he was doing anything wrong, and therefore was not given any opportunity to fix it. The Courts view the trial period as something that both employer and employee will work at, to try and ensure it will be a success. This will all now be a part of acting in "good faith".

If an employer has set out in writing the existence of a trial period for a specified time, the employer needs to ensure that a clause is also included to allow the employer to dismiss the employee (following a proper and fair investigation) for misconduct. If this clause is not included and the employer dismisses the probationary employee, the employee can claim lost wages to the end of the probationary period, not to mention compensation for stress and humiliation etc.

Best advice - seek professional advice first, before commencing any disciplinary proceedings, or where the employee is not performing adequately under the trial period.

The information contained in this outline is of a general nature, should only be used as a guide and does not amount to legal advice. It should not be used or relied upon as a substitute for detailed advice or as a basis for formulating decisions. Special considerations apply to individual fact situations. Before acting, clients should consult their lawyer.

This artice written by Agnes McKay of Legal Alternative Ltd


More on Employment Agreements

  Employee trial periods   Disputes resolution procedure must be included in staff agreement   Cannot limit remedies for personal grievances
  More on secret video cameras   Renegotiation of employment contract on sale of business   Cannot dismiss without reason even if written in agreement
  When is an employment relationship formed?   Expired contracts continue with same terms and conditions   Can a collective employment contract negotiated with union members be applied to non union members?
  Employer can still be bound by oral agreements   Can change pay frequency if properly managed   Employee must disclose information at interview only if asked
  Common problems with employment agreements   Appeal Court decision on harsh and oppressive contracts   Cannot require all employees to apply for new positions
  Take care when preparing employment agreements   Employment contracts must be negotiated - they cannot just be presented   What an offer of employment might look like
  Importance of disclosing correct employer   Discrimination for being on collective employment contract  
  Alphabetical Index   Case Law Back to top
Copyright © 1985 - 2009 Ace Payroll
Feedback? E-Mail Us!
Call Toll Free
0800 223 729
Updated: 3rd January 2009
Published: 13th November 2002
Back to top